IoT controller vs PLC: which one the point needs

The question usually arrives as "can this replace a PLC", and the honest answer is no. A PLC runs a machine on a deterministic cycle with a safety rating behind it. A cellular IoT controller covers the points a PLC is uneconomic for: distributed, unpowered, outside any panel.

Side by side

PLCCellular IoT controller
Built toRun a machine or a process cellMeasure, report and switch at distributed points
TimingDeterministic scan cycleReadings on intervals set from the cloud
LogicIEC 61131-3 programsThresholds and simple rules held on the device
SafetySafety-rated variants existNo safety rating
InstallationA panel, mains power and a networkBattery or solar, cellular, no cabinet
Where data goesTo a SCADA or HMI on the site networkTo a cloud with alerts, export and a REST API

Which one, when

Use a PLC for the machine

Interlocks, sequences, motion and anything that protects people or plant belong on a PLC or a safety controller.

Use an IoT controller between the machines

A tank at the end of the yard, a pump in an outbuilding, a cold room on another site: points where a panel build costs more than the measurement is worth.

Use both together

The PLC runs the line. The IoT controller watches the utilities around it and reports to people who are not on the site network.

Where Genesis sits

Genesis reads RS485 Modbus, analogue, I2C and 1-Wire sensors on four ports set from the dashboard, runs on battery and solar, and reports over 4G-LTE. It switches relays and solenoids on rules held on the device.

It is sold for the points between machines. It is not sold as a PLC, and it should not be specified as one.

Related

Frequently asked questions

Can an IoT controller read data from our PLC?

Where the PLC exposes values on RS485 Modbus RTU, a register map is enough to add it as a supported device.

Can it close a loop?

Simple ones, such as starting a transfer pump on a level, with the rule held on the device. Anything time-critical or safety-related stays on the PLC.

Not sure which one the site needs?

Tell us what has to be measured or switched, where, and what it has to report into. We say which approach fits, including when it is not ours.

Talk to us →